The Bible repeatedly warns that the greatest spiritual dangers do not arise from open paganism, but from counterfeit spirituality that mimics the language of faith while denying its substance. Jesus cautioned that false prophets would come in sheep’s clothing (Matthew 7:15), not announcing themselves as enemies of truth, but appearing righteous while leading many astray. For this reason, discernment is not optional for the Church; it is an act of obedience, love, and pastoral responsibility (1 John 4:1).
Authentic faith does not fear spiritual gifts or the supernatural; it fears deception. And deception is most effective when it feels familiar.
Biblical Witchcraft: A Matter of Trust, Not Technique
Scripture defines witchcraft not merely as occult ritual, but as the attempt to access or control spiritual power apart from submission to God’s authority. In 1 Samuel 15:23, rebellion against God’s command is likened to witchcraft because both elevate the human will above God’s rule. In Galatians 5:20, Paul lists pharmakeia alongside idolatry as a work of the flesh, revealing that the core issue is misplaced trust, not outward appearance.
This means Scripture condemns witchcraft not primarily because of strange behavior, but because it attempts to secure spiritual power without surrender to the Lord. Any system—religious or secular—that promises spiritual results without dependence on God reflects this impulse.
Before proceeding, it must be stated clearly what this discernment is not condemning. The Bible affirms that God heals, provides, and works powerfully through prayer. Scripture teaches the ongoing work of the Holy Spirit and the reality of spiritual gifts (1 Corinthians 12–14). The concern addressed here is not belief in God’s power, but the reduction of that power into a system—where outcomes are promised through technique rather than entrusted to God’s sovereign will.
The Question We Must Ask: Can Christian Teaching Function Like Witchcraft?
With this framework in place, we must ask an uncomfortable but necessary question:
Can teachings that use Christian language still function as witchcraft in practice?
Scripture compels us to answer yes.
In many modern expressions of the Prosperity Gospel and Word of Faith theology, faith is presented not as humble trust in God, but as a spiritual mechanism. Believers are taught that words create reality, that spoken declarations activate spiritual laws, and that blessings can be secured through proper verbal alignment. Prayer subtly shifts from dependent petition to authoritative proclamation, and God’s will is replaced by predictable outcomes.
These ideas are often defended through isolated biblical phrases about asking, believing, speaking, or blessing. Yet when such passages are removed from their covenantal and narrative context, they are transformed into guarantees Scripture never gives. Biblical promises are relational, not mechanical. They are grounded in God’s character, not human precision. When Scripture is treated as a manual for activation rather than revelation, faith is quietly redefined.
The Biblical Pattern: Faith Submits, It Does Not Control
This represents a fundamental departure from biblical faith. In Scripture, faith is never a force that obligates God. It is trust in God’s wisdom even when His purposes include suffering, loss, or delay. Hebrews 11 presents faith not only in miraculous deliverance, but also in endurance under persecution, poverty, imprisonment, and death.
Even Jesus Himself entrusted His will to the Father in Gethsemane rather than declaring escape from suffering. The apostles experienced frequent affliction, not because they lacked faith, but because they possessed it (2 Corinthians 4:7–12).
When words are treated as inherently powerful rather than as expressions of prayer and truth, spiritual authority is transferred from God to method. When believers are taught that negative speech blocks blessing, responsibility for unanswered prayer shifts from God’s wisdom to human performance. When success and health become measures of faith, the cross is emptied of its meaning.
This is where such teaching mirrors witchcraft—not in appearance, but in function. Witchcraft seeks control over spiritual outcomes through method. Biblical faith seeks obedience regardless of outcome. Witchcraft elevates technique. Biblical faith clings to revelation. Witchcraft promises power without submission. The gospel calls for submission before power.
James confronts this distortion by explaining that unanswered prayer often exposes wrong motives, not faulty technique (James 4:3). Paul teaches that God’s power is perfected in weakness, not mastery (2 Corinthians 12:9). The Holy Spirit is never presented as an impersonal force to be activated, but as God Himself who acts according to His will.
The Cost of Rejecting Formula-Based Religion
Rejecting formula-based faith carries a real cost. Systems that promise guaranteed outcomes offer certainty and control, while biblical faith requires:
• Waiting without answers (Isaiah 55:8–9)
• Obedience without visible reward (Daniel 3)
• Trust amid suffering (James 1:2–4; 1 Peter 1:6–7)
Yet Scripture consistently presents costly trust not as failure, but as maturity. Christlikeness is forged not in constant victory, but in perseverance, humility, and dependence.
Historical Echoes: Ancient Errors in Modern Form
These modern teachings are not new. Throughout Church history, movements have arisen that promise secret knowledge, spiritual laws, or divine techniques that bypass surrender to God.
• Gnosticism offered enlightenment without repentance.
• Pelagianism emphasized human ability over divine grace.
• New Thought (19th-century metaphysical movement) taught that words and thoughts reshape reality—ideas that feed directly into Word of Faith theology.
Even Israel fell into this pattern. In Jeremiah’s day, the people trusted in the temple, believing they were safe because they possessed a sacred object—without submitting to God. In the New Testament, the seven sons of Sceva attempted to use Jesus’ name like a formula—and were destroyed (Acts 19:13–16). The danger is not theoretical; it is recurring.
When Discernment Requires Naming Names
Because doctrine shapes devotion, Scripture repeatedly instructs shepherds to warn the flock (Acts 20:28–31). Love does not require silence when teachings consistently distort the gospel and train believers to manipulate God rather than submit to Him.
For this reason, Christians should be concerned about and avoid the teachings of public teachers whose core doctrines repeatedly reflect faith-as-force, verbal activation, decrees, spiritual laws, and guaranteed outcomes. The following names are not listed to judge motives or salvation, but because their published teachings align with what Scripture defines as rebellion-based, manipulative spirituality:
Kenneth Copeland, Creflo Dollar, Bill Johnson, Benny Hinn, Joel Osteen, Joseph Prince, Todd White, Joyce Meyer, Andrew Wommack
These ministries consistently teach concepts such as creative speech, faith as a force, decrees that establish reality, spiritual laws that obligate God, guaranteed healing or prosperity, and outcome-centered faith. These ideas shift trust away from God’s sovereignty and toward human technique, which is precisely the posture Scripture condemns when it defines witchcraft as rebellion.
It must be said clearly: this does not mean every listener is knowingly rebellious, every miracle claim is false, or every charismatic believer is practicing witchcraft. Deception often thrives among sincere people who have never been taught discernment. Scripture instructs us to correct with gentleness (2 Timothy 2:25), while still naming danger plainly.
A Call to Self-Examination
Discernment must also turn inward. Every believer must examine how they pray, what they expect faith to produce, and whether they equate God’s favor with comfort or success. The temptation to control outcomes rather than trust God’s wisdom is not limited to movements or ministries; it resides in the human heart.
True Spirit-led ministry produces humility, repentance, endurance, and holiness. Counterfeit spirituality produces confidence in technique, fixation on outcomes, and avoidance of suffering. One conforms believers to Christ; the other subtly trains them to use Christ.
Clarifying Charismatic Ministry
It is important to recognize that God’s gifts—the prophetic, healing, tongues, deliverance, and miracles—are real and good when exercised under His authority. The concern is not the presence of supernatural ministry, but the replacement of relationship with method. Charismatic experiences can be biblical and beautiful—when God leads, rather than formula.
Recovering the Heart of Biblical Faith
The Church must recover the biblical posture of faith—one that:
• Prays boldly yet submits fully
• Believes God for miracles yet trusts Him in suffering
• Seeks His glory rather than guaranteed results
Any teaching that replaces that posture with formulas, decrees, or spiritual laws may sound powerful, but it ultimately leads believers away from the Lordship of Christ.
The cross—not technique—is the center of Christian spirituality.
Signs of Healthy, God-Centered Faith
To help believers self-examine and grow, biblical faith consistently produces:
• Submission to God’s will
• Trust in His sovereignty
• Humility before God and others
• Repentance and conviction of sin
• Patience in suffering
• Endurance in trials
• Transparency and accountability in community
• Pursuit of holiness over visible reward
Conclusion: Discernment as Love and Fidelity
Discernment is not about fear or accusation. It is about fidelity. It is about guarding the flock from systems that promise control instead of calling for the cross. And it is about returning, again and again, to the simple, costly, glorious truth that God is God, and we are not.
This version integrates historical context, clarifies biblical support, affirms charismatic gifts, adds hope and practical self-examination, emphasizes healthy signs of faith, and reinforces that discernment is an act of love.
Feeding the Flock Ministry 
Leave a comment